CASE ANALYSIS SUMMARY
Bottom Line: This case involved a physician who voluntarily surrendered their New York medical license rather than contest charges related to their Kentucky license revocation. The physician had been disciplined in Kentucky for failing to properly diagnose and monitor 11 patients, maintaining substandard medical records, and refusing to participate in rehabilitation proceedings. Rather than face a hearing in New York on reciprocal disciplinary charges, the physician chose to surrender their license voluntarily, agreeing to extensive practice closure requirements.
DETAILED CASE ANALYSIS
Effective Date: December 7, 2011 (effective December 14, 2011)
Type of Doctor: Medical Doctor (M.D.) licensed to practice medicine in New York State (License #116807, issued July 16, 1973)
Disposition Type: Voluntary surrender of license (negotiated consent)
How many total charges? 2 specifications of professional misconduct
What specifications of charges were alleged?
-
- First Specification: Violation of New York Education Law §6530(9)(b) – being found guilty of improper professional practice or professional misconduct by another state’s professional disciplinary agency, where the underlying conduct would constitute professional misconduct under New York law
- Second Specification: Violation of New York Education Law §6530(9)(d) – having license revoked and/or having other disciplinary action taken by another state’s professional disciplinary agency, where the underlying conduct would constitute professional misconduct under New York law
How many patients were involved in each charge? 11 patients were specifically mentioned in the underlying Kentucky disciplinary action for failure to diagnose and monitor at minimum standards of care
Which charges was the licensee guilty of (either via hearing or negotiated consent)? The physician did not contest either charge and voluntarily surrendered their license, effectively accepting responsibility for both specifications:
- First Specification: Not contested (voluntary surrender)
- Second Specification: Not contested (voluntary surrender)
Which charges was the licensee not guilty of? The physician chose not to contest any charges through voluntary surrender, so there were no not-guilty findings.
Outcome/Penalties (specific to this case):
-
- Primary Penalty: Voluntary surrender of license to practice medicine in New York State
- Name removed from physician roster in New York
- Extensive Practice Closure Requirements including:
- Immediate cessation of medical practice
- Patient notification within 15 days
- Medical records transfer arrangements within 30 days
- Surrender of DEA certificate and controlled substance privileges
- Return of prescription forms within 15 days
- Cessation of all medical advertising and professional representations
- Divestiture of financial interests in medical corporations within 90 days
- Underlying Kentucky Disciplinary Action: License revocation for failing to diagnose and monitor 11 patients, keeping records below minimum standards of care, and refusing to participate in Kentucky proceedings, demonstrating incapability of rehabilitation
- Process Note: This was a voluntary surrender application by the physician rather than a contested hearing, allowing him to avoid the “risks and burdens of a hearing on the merits”
The physician specifically stated he was surrendering “of my own free will and not under duress, compulsion or restraint” and waived his right to contest the surrender order administratively or judicially.